close
close
close
Mom's Daily Dose
recent posts
close
Mamapop!
recent posts
close
The Advice Smackdown
recent posts
about me
archives
links
twitter
subscribe (rss)
 
mamapop
the advice smackdown
zero to forty
bounce back

« Let's Just Call This One "Tuesday" | Main | It was either us or them at this point »

Lunch Bunch Dropout

January 17, 2008

So I quit Lunch Bunch yesterday. And the one-on-one occupational therapy.

(The eyeballs of several trolls just rolled completely out of their heads and out into traffic. Quick! Run after them!)

I pretty much knew it was time to quit after last week, and then Noah's success in his Thursday Non-Lunch-Bunch class confirmed what I already suspected: Noah did not like his occupational therapist, and she didn't quite seem to like him very much either, and no, the marriage could not be saved and was probably doomed from the day she walked into our house and then tried to rub his face with the duckie washcloth 15 seconds after saying hi.

We moved OT from our house to the early intervention center. We added group therapy and a special ed teacher and yet, no progress.

I should have listened to my gut and just called and requested a new therapist. But lo, I am pussy, hear me puss out. I kept giving it one more week, another try, another chance for Noah to snap out it because dude, she hasn't touched your face in months! Chill out. Eat some pudding.

Then last week she called him a brat.

She. Called. Him. A Brat.

I cannot even tell you what it felt like to hear that -- especially after weeks of frayed nerves and nonstop worry; especially hearing it in the one place where special needs children are supposed to be understood and accepted. But because Noah was not getting any better, she decided that it was not her, it was him. Since she'd been unable to help him, his panic and screaming and refusal to do anything she asked were not sensory at all, but were "just him being a B-R-A-T."

I guess I should give her points for spelling it, since Noah was within earshot. But my heart clenched and my hair stood up on the back of my neck and Dear Internet Confessional, I have never, ever come so close to whipping my earrings out and lunging at someone's hair.

But instead, I just. Sat there. Dumbfounded. Because...mother h. fucker, Noah is one of the least bratty children in the world, swear to God, and I would really tell you if I believed otherwise. He is strong-willed, he is sensitive, he is difficult in his own difficult-to-define way. He is also calm and meticulous, empathetic beyond his years, loving and affectionate and just an all-around sweetheart. (I know, I know, he is also the most beautiful child who ever walked the earth and the smartest and his poop smells like flowers blah blah mama-delusion-cakes.)

I'm so disappointed that I just sat there. I think I maybe stammered that...uh...actually I don't think so, I think there might be some TRUST ISSUES at play here (what with her insistence that if we just forcibly hold him on top of the exercise ball, eventually he'll stop being scared of the exercise ball, GAH GAH GAH DID YOU LEARN EVERYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT SENSORY INTEGRATION DISORDER FROM THE BACK OF A CEREAL BOX?).

I should have said something else, or marched down to the office and demanded a new therapist right then and there, but I didn't. I sat there, in a little crumpled pile of defeat.

And then, Thursday.

That occupational therapist told me that Noah did need support to stay with the group, but she gave him that support and he stayed with the group. And he needed a lot of extra time to process transitions. While they gave the rest of the class a one-minute warning between activities, Noah got one at five minutes, and four, three, two and one. He needed time alone when he got overwhelmed -- they let him hide under a slide for a few minutes whenever they sensed the noise of the room was starting to get to him. Every teacher in the room was willing and able to help him, and he clearly adored them by the end of the hour. One hour, and total preschool-ready victory was achieved.

And then, yesterday. Lunch Bunch. With her. Once again, an exhausting, tantrummy mess. Noah did sit for awhile (only after some help from a random therapist who was there to observe) and fed some plastic fruit to a puppet. But it was obvious that he was not being all he could be. She suggested that perhaps we should drop all this and let Noah focus on his Thursday class. She told me I could think about it.

I thought about it. Five minutes later I signed the paperwork agreeing to end OT services. It felt good. It was the right thing to do.

The right thing for NOW, anyway. Let me say, while the therapy itself was usually kind of tortuous, there's no denying that Noah is a totally different kid now. Her bedside manner may have left something to be desired (she actually always sort of reminded me of my very first lactation consultant, a woman who can still make me cry just by passing by me in the pediatrician's office hallway), but she gave us tons of stuff to try and activities to do and ways to incorporate therapy into everyday play. And it all worked. I mean, SLIDES. HE GOES DOWN SLIDES. He jumps! He walks up the stairs sometimes! He no longer toe-walks and rarely falls. He eats...well, he eats a few more things, but no longer seems completely repulsed by certain textures or the feel of a fork. We will continue with the class on Thursday, and if I think he needs more OT services, I will request them from the therapist from there. Noah gave her a hug last week. I think he likes her. I like her. But I think we've cleared that particular hurdle.

While his speech started improving almost immediately after we started Early Intervention, we only really got the big language explosion AFTER we saw the OT-related improvements.   Maybe I should have switched therapists, maybe it could have been easier, maybe it all would have corrected itself on its own.  In the end, though, I can't argue with success, however we found it.

I officially enrolled Noah in a preschool this morning. And I think the little brat is going to do just fine.

Photo_32

Posted at 02:13 PM in Noah, SPD, speech delays | Permalink

Comments

OMG-Amalah I am so sorry that this happened to you and Noah. He isn't...I promise. I can't believe that she would have said (or spelled) it.
Good for you to stand up to the situation. You know more about what he needs now - obviously she does not...I am sure that between your new knowledge and his new preschool, he will do just fine!

Posted by: Nichole | January 17, 2008 at 02:17 PM

Good for you , Amy.
I'm rubber your glue, whatever you say bounces off of me and sticks to you. :-)
I'm glad to know Noah has improved despite the therapist issues.

Posted by: angela | January 17, 2008 at 02:22 PM

Those brown eyes. Gah. They make my heart explode.

Congrats on making a hard decision, lovely.

Posted by: Spring | January 17, 2008 at 02:22 PM

I am impressed with your restraint. A picture of the therapist flat on her back after you knocked her out would have made for great blog fodder. Oh well. I'm glad Noah is doing so much better. I can't wait to read the chronicles of preschool as told by Noah, narrated by Amy.

Posted by: Someone Being Me | January 17, 2008 at 02:23 PM

"I'm rubber your glue, whatever you say bounces off of me and sticks to you. :-)"
That part of my comment was directed to the therapist, in case you didn't catch that.

Posted by: angela | January 17, 2008 at 02:27 PM

Wow. Not acceptable. It is her job--her job--to figure out alternative approaches if something isn't working. I have to admit I was shocked to hear that she went after him with a washcloth at the very beginning. Scooter has sensory issues too, and they have improved a bit with OT. But his therapists did this by addressing gross motor skills and getting him to learn to control his body. The sensory and speech improvements came along for the ride.

I can't sing the praises of OT enough, but I would have pulled him out of a situation like that too. And how could she not like Noah? Stubborn and sensitive does not a brat make!

Posted by: Mouse | January 17, 2008 at 02:27 PM

Holy crap. What a b*tch. We had one fill-in OT that was horrid, but never called my kid a name. Onward! Here's to lots of fun times in preschool!

Posted by: HeatherK | January 17, 2008 at 02:27 PM

Your little one is clearly far from a brat, and is, in fact, the cutest child ever. Good for you for making the decision that is the best for you AND Noah. He will be just fine.

Posted by: Jenny | January 17, 2008 at 02:29 PM

What a B-I-O-T-C-H she was to say that.

Posted by: All Adither | January 17, 2008 at 02:29 PM

I don't usually post. And I know you've thought about this. But you are going to tell someone in a position of authority why you are leaving?

Posted by: M&Co. | January 17, 2008 at 02:31 PM

I hope you reported that woman. That was completely inappropriate and unprofessional.

Posted by: kalisah | January 17, 2008 at 02:31 PM

Good for you, Amalah. Listening to the gut is a good, good, oh-so-good thing, and not just with regard to tasty cheese selections.

Posted by: kelly | January 17, 2008 at 02:32 PM

There's an entire Internet whose hair stood up when we read that too.

He's going to do beautifully. We can't wait to see all he does and becomes.

Posted by: She Likes Purple | January 17, 2008 at 02:32 PM

I don't even have children, but reading that whole "brat" part made me cringe. INAPPROPRIATE!

Posted by: Marriage-101 | January 17, 2008 at 02:34 PM

Oh god, I know just how you feel. And if you're like me, you'll play the scene back over and over in your mind saying and doing what you *wish* you'd said and done and it will make you crazy. Crazier. Whatever. Anyway, my heart jumped into my throat when I read that, because if anyone ever called my son a brat, I think I'd explode. I mean, I'M allowed to call him that, but no one else.

Posted by: Amy :) | January 17, 2008 at 02:35 PM

Okay- I know I will be a lone voice in the list of moms congratulating themselves on- well everything- but I can assure you, parents are not the best judges of if their children are brats. You are supposed to be the number one supporter- that makes you blind to what others can see. Am I saying Noah is a brat? Hardly, I have never met him. But neither have most of you. Being adorable and having a lovely mother who is a great writer does not make exclude you from being a brat.

Posted by: Ready for the insults | January 17, 2008 at 02:35 PM

Noah is the least batty kid I've ever seen. Michael is a bratty kid.

Um, I'm so offended, and trying really not hard not to inform everyone I know in that office how much she sucks.

Posted by: jodi | January 17, 2008 at 02:35 PM

I want to open up a can of whoop-B-U-T-T all over that therapist on behalf of you and The Noah.

Posted by: Missie | January 17, 2008 at 02:36 PM

I totally would have reacted to the "B-R-A-T" comment the same way. But now, could I please have her name and number so I can personally kick her ass?

Posted by: Mandee | January 17, 2008 at 02:37 PM

That woman is a disgrace. Good for you - doing what you knew was best for Noah.

Not the same, but we pulled our 5 year old out of Kindergarten because he was exhibiting signs of depression. I am convinced that a lot of it was thanks to his teacher. We as parents knew what we had to do and did it. Luc is a much happier kid for it.

I too, can't believe you didn't knock her flat! You have more restraint than I.

Posted by: Janelle | January 17, 2008 at 02:39 PM

How out of line that therapist was! On so many levels! I kinda wished you lunged for her hair, though.

Best of luck with pre-school, and, I assume, potty training.

Posted by: Penny | January 17, 2008 at 02:40 PM

Preschool will be so much fun. Good for you for doing what you think is right for him.

Posted by: Kristin | January 17, 2008 at 02:41 PM

Holy crap. I may THINK a kid is a brat, and I may mutter it to my husband but there is NO WAY on Earth that I would even consider for one second saying it to their parents.

Is this the same group that he did so well in last week? Was it just last week?

Posted by: Jenn | January 17, 2008 at 02:41 PM

OMG!! I cannot believe she said that to you guys!!! Noah's adorable! Though I don't know you personally, nothing you have ever said about him puts him anywhere in a "brat" catagory. It's when people act like that that gets you wondering why in the world they went into a pediatric field to begin with!!! Ugh... I'm sorry. I'm sure Noah will do great in preschool!!

Posted by: Ariel | January 17, 2008 at 02:43 PM

That was so out of line. My son currently gets OT services and I would fall over if our therapist ever said that. Not out of anger but out of shock! (well and a little anger)
Their JOB is to help you not to make excuses why it's not working.
Arghhh! I so hope you told someone higher up about it.
Good luck with preschool.

Posted by: Dani | January 17, 2008 at 02:47 PM

That was so out of line. My son currently gets OT services and I would fall over if our therapist ever said that. Not out of anger but out of shock! (well and a little anger)
Their JOB is to help you not to make excuses why it's not working.
Arghhh! I so hope you told someone higher up about it.
Good luck with preschool. :)

Posted by: Dani | January 17, 2008 at 02:47 PM

Is it wrong that I would have responded to your (former) OT one-on-one with: "No, you're just being a B-I-T-C-H"?

(If it is wrong, I don't want to be right - I'll turn the other cheek if you insult me, but come after my family and there will be hell to pay.)

Anyway, I'm so happy that Noah has made such tremendous strides recently and that you've found an environment that's helping him to thrive. Go Team Storch!

Posted by: Gabrielle | January 17, 2008 at 02:50 PM

That's funny since I'm always talking about that brat, Noah, whose face is all over my office. Gosh, such a nuisance that one.

Posted by: Heather B. | January 17, 2008 at 02:52 PM

How unprofessional of her. Therapists are taught skill, but can't always be taught compassion and tact. You should think about reporting it to her supervisor.

Posted by: Nosaby | January 17, 2008 at 02:55 PM

A smackdown would not have been out of line. What an unprofessional and rude comment.

Posted by: Kim | January 17, 2008 at 02:56 PM

Good for you! A hard decision, and you made it. I would have been seeing red if that woman talked about my child that way. Please tell me that you intend to report her. She should not be in the position she's in.

Noah's going to be great. He already is great. He's two. Lots of time to overcome his various little problems. I personally think he's going to do just fine.

Posted by: Judy | January 17, 2008 at 02:57 PM

What a rude comment by the OT! Good on you for going with your instincts and knowing what's best for Noah. He'll be fine!

Posted by: Kerry | January 17, 2008 at 03:02 PM

I've been reading forever and the one thing Noah is NOT is a brat. That's terribly unfair and ridiculous to label him as just being a jerk, he's not behaving strangely because it's FUN for him. Obviously he's having some troubles with things, just because she feels she can't help doesn't make him a brat.

That lady oughta be reported. I can understand getting frustrated, but a professional who is supposed to be there to help your child really shouldn't be calling him names.

Posted by: kat | January 17, 2008 at 03:03 PM

Amy, maybe she was just acting that way because she's a B-I-T-C-H.

I hate to hear that someone said that about Noah. It makes me want to kick her ass.

Posted by: Jennifer | January 17, 2008 at 03:04 PM

I am so going to miss the funny "Lunch Bunch" recaps. Just keep posting cute smiley pics of Noah, though, and I'll keep checking back!

Posted by: Pamela | January 17, 2008 at 03:04 PM

While I think the therapist was out of line, no question, are you sure you want to pull him out of the interventions completely? He seems to have made many strides lately but still to have some issues to overcome. Not that it matters what I think (at all, it is your kid!) but perhaps shopping around for a different therapist would be a good idea?

Posted by: Ker | January 17, 2008 at 03:04 PM

I second, or third, or whatever the "you need to tell her boss" comments. It is inexcusable for an OT to make a comment like that to a parent. "Headstrong", for instance, may have been a better word choice. Our son hated his OT also. She consistantly worse-cased everything about him when all other therapists disagreed. We finally fired her ourselves and asked the county for a different one. Soooooo much nicer now. When you decide to go back to OT you'll be far less complacent - and that's a good thing.

Posted by: imstell | January 17, 2008 at 03:08 PM

Your gut: it's smart.
Have your own personal Lunch Bunch at a McDonalds...with slides.

Want to poke that woman's eyes out.

Posted by: KimAZ | January 17, 2008 at 03:08 PM

You're such a good person. Bitch would have been missin' her two front teeth if I would have heard it.

Noah will be fine, you'll do what's best for him in your own way, because that's what you do. :)

Posted by: verybadcat | January 17, 2008 at 03:10 PM

I think that therapist may have been the bigger B-R-A-T than Noah. I'm sure he's going to do great in preschool. And you're going to do great without that woman!

Posted by: Z | January 17, 2008 at 03:10 PM

I haven't read your whole entry - or the comments; but I hope that you aren't beating yourself up about waiting to make a change. You're the mother not the expert - without the expert education it takes parents a while to figure out whats right and whats wrong. Also, sometimes people are not in the right careers - much like my son's guidance counselor who encouraged us to take him out of school; in front of my son.

Posted by: cursingmama | January 17, 2008 at 03:11 PM

One note - we are NOT pulling him out of services completely. Definitely NOT.

He will still attend the class on Thursdays -- it's called Kids At Play and it's a Hanen/language/combo class and there is an OT present to help Noah and a couple other kids with issues similar to his. It's fantastic because it blends the language development stuff and the sensory stuff together, all in a mock preschool setting.

It was canceled today because of snow, boo.

Posted by: Amalah | January 17, 2008 at 03:15 PM

You did the right thing. Sounds like this woman was not willing to be the adult in this situation and get over the personality conflict.

I swear we're living parallel lives sometimes. Cordy's PT sounds a lot like your OT. Only we can't request another, because she's the only one assigned to that school. I was going to post soon about how I found out Cordy's PT told an outside person in the classroom that Cordy was "trouble" and "don't let her fool you"! I'm still trying to cool down before I post about it.

Posted by: Christina | January 17, 2008 at 03:16 PM

Are you going to write a letter to...someone...about that? I would. Dude.

Posted by: Nancy | January 17, 2008 at 03:18 PM

Are you going to inform her supervisor? Becausing calling a kid a B-R-A-T is such a no-no, even if they really are being a brat. It sounds like Noah is on the right track; Jr was the same way and still is. He'll drag his feet for most of the school year and then BLAMMO! He's suddenly doing what we've been asking him to do all frickin' year. And yay for sliding! And talking!

Posted by: warcrygirl | January 17, 2008 at 03:20 PM

dude, you need to report her. because she should NOT be allowed to treat children that way. especially children in OT ... it's pretty standard that you have to build trust before introducing new stimuli (like a duckie face cloth).

her bosses need to know that she treated you that way.

Posted by: robyn | January 17, 2008 at 03:24 PM

Ok, I have to say that I have not a lot of input on the therapy because I have no children, but I think that following your gut is a good thing.

But, more importantly? I LOVE THAT PICTURE!!! I just want to pinch his cheeks and put him in my pocket for safe-keeping.

Posted by: Cassie | January 17, 2008 at 03:25 PM

Christina! OMG and WTF. And that's why I waited a whole week to post this...took me that long to calm down.

And you know what? Even if Noah really was the brattiest brat who ever bratted, no one gets to actually call him that but me.

And again, I swear, the behavior she saw was Noah In Distress, not Noah Negotiating For A Better Outcome Like Cookays.

Posted by: Amalah | January 17, 2008 at 03:27 PM

I will totally go Ozark on her for you. What an ignorant thing for her to say. Hang in there, mama.

Posted by: Dana | January 17, 2008 at 03:27 PM

Calling Noah a B-R-A-T is not only inaccurate, it is completely unprofessional. I'm proud of you for making that decision.

Posted by: Valerie | January 17, 2008 at 03:28 PM
MORE COMMENTS»

The comments to this entry are closed.

Advertise on amalah with FM

2007 weblog award winner: best parenting blog

BlogWithIntegrity.com align="center">

© Copyright 2003-2008 amalah dot com ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Site design by Sean Slinsky, powered by Typepad