Lunch Bunch Dropout
January 17, 2008
So I quit Lunch Bunch yesterday. And the one-on-one occupational therapy.
(The eyeballs of several trolls just rolled completely out of their heads and out into traffic. Quick! Run after them!)
I pretty much knew it was time to quit after last week, and then Noah's success in his Thursday Non-Lunch-Bunch class confirmed what I already suspected: Noah did not like his occupational therapist, and she didn't quite seem to like him very much either, and no, the marriage could not be saved and was probably doomed from the day she walked into our house and then tried to rub his face with the duckie washcloth 15 seconds after saying hi.
We moved OT from our house to the early intervention center. We added group therapy and a special ed teacher and yet, no progress.
I should have listened to my gut and just called and requested a new therapist. But lo, I am pussy, hear me puss out. I kept giving it one more week, another try, another chance for Noah to snap out it because dude, she hasn't touched your face in months! Chill out. Eat some pudding.
Then last week she called him a brat.
She. Called. Him. A Brat.
I cannot even tell you what it felt like to hear that -- especially after weeks of frayed nerves and nonstop worry; especially hearing it in the one place where special needs children are supposed to be understood and accepted. But because Noah was not getting any better, she decided that it was not her, it was him. Since she'd been unable to help him, his panic and screaming and refusal to do anything she asked were not sensory at all, but were "just him being a B-R-A-T."
I guess I should give her points for spelling it, since Noah was within earshot. But my heart clenched and my hair stood up on the back of my neck and Dear Internet Confessional, I have never, ever come so close to whipping my earrings out and lunging at someone's hair.
But instead, I just. Sat there. Dumbfounded. Because...mother h. fucker, Noah is one of the least bratty children in the world, swear to God, and I would really tell you if I believed otherwise. He is strong-willed, he is sensitive, he is difficult in his own difficult-to-define way. He is also calm and meticulous, empathetic beyond his years, loving and affectionate and just an all-around sweetheart. (I know, I know, he is also the most beautiful child who ever walked the earth and the smartest and his poop smells like flowers blah blah mama-delusion-cakes.)
I'm so disappointed that I just sat there. I think I maybe stammered that...uh...actually I don't think so, I think there might be some TRUST ISSUES at play here (what with her insistence that if we just forcibly hold him on top of the exercise ball, eventually he'll stop being scared of the exercise ball, GAH GAH GAH DID YOU LEARN EVERYTHING YOU KNOW ABOUT SENSORY INTEGRATION DISORDER FROM THE BACK OF A CEREAL BOX?).
I should have said something else, or marched down to the office and demanded a new therapist right then and there, but I didn't. I sat there, in a little crumpled pile of defeat.
And then, Thursday.
That occupational therapist told me that Noah did need support to stay with the group, but she gave him that support and he stayed with the group. And he needed a lot of extra time to process transitions. While they gave the rest of the class a one-minute warning between activities, Noah got one at five minutes, and four, three, two and one. He needed time alone when he got overwhelmed -- they let him hide under a slide for a few minutes whenever they sensed the noise of the room was starting to get to him. Every teacher in the room was willing and able to help him, and he clearly adored them by the end of the hour. One hour, and total preschool-ready victory was achieved.
And then, yesterday. Lunch Bunch. With her. Once again, an exhausting, tantrummy mess. Noah did sit for awhile (only after some help from a random therapist who was there to observe) and fed some plastic fruit to a puppet. But it was obvious that he was not being all he could be. She suggested that perhaps we should drop all this and let Noah focus on his Thursday class. She told me I could think about it.
I thought about it. Five minutes later I signed the paperwork agreeing to end OT services. It felt good. It was the right thing to do.
The right thing for NOW, anyway. Let me say, while the therapy itself was usually kind of tortuous, there's no denying that Noah is a totally different kid now. Her bedside manner may have left something to be desired (she actually always sort of reminded me of my very first lactation consultant, a woman who can still make me cry just by passing by me in the pediatrician's office hallway), but she gave us tons of stuff to try and activities to do and ways to incorporate therapy into everyday play. And it all worked. I mean, SLIDES. HE GOES DOWN SLIDES. He jumps! He walks up the stairs sometimes! He no longer toe-walks and rarely falls. He eats...well, he eats a few more things, but no longer seems completely repulsed by certain textures or the feel of a fork. We will continue with the class on Thursday, and if I think he needs more OT services, I will request them from the therapist from there. Noah gave her a hug last week. I think he likes her. I like her. But I think we've cleared that particular hurdle.
While his speech started improving almost immediately after we started Early Intervention, we only really got the big language explosion AFTER we saw the OT-related improvements. Maybe I should have switched therapists, maybe it could have been easier, maybe it all would have corrected itself on its own. In the end, though, I can't argue with success, however we found it.
I officially enrolled Noah in a preschool this morning. And I think the little brat is going to do just fine.



100% agree with everyone who says you should report this. Maybe Noah didn't understand what she was spelling, but you did, and these sessions aren't just for him. Her job is to make him better and to make you feel better about the whole ordeal, and she failed to do so on a number of levels, but especially that one. You can't just snicker behind a child's back like that.
Maybe take some time to cool down before calling (I always do, so that when I have a complaint about someone else's immaturity, they don't end up rolling their eyes at me blowing my top off and say, "Yeah, tell me about it"), but if she thinks it's acceptable to say that, she's wrong. Whether it's true or not (and I trust your self-judgment: it's not), no professional has the right to say that, least of all in front of the mother she's trying to help.
I think you should get bonus points for not putting vaseline on your face, rolling up your sleeves, and taking her down.
WOW! I've lurked here for a while; I have a daughter that is substantially similar to Noah in a lot of ways and I've enjoyed reading your blog to know that I'm not navigating these strange waters alone.
I'm not sure that I could have controlled myself from punching that woman out. And if I had controlled myself, I would have most likely just melted into a puddle of crying, since I'm like that when I'm angry.
You did the right things! Therapy that's not working is just not worth the time and is counterproductive. Here's to preschool without that crazed lunatic of an OT!
(Look at me with the comments! My site is going to start CAPTCHA-ing me to prove I'm not a spammy robot.)
Yes, I am going to talk to our case manager about it. She was our in-home speech therapist and knows beyond a shadow of doubt that Noah is not a brat. At least not 99% of the time. He just has the memory of an elephant when it comes to people and washcloths.
Wow! How bloody unprofessional is that? Blame it on the special needs kid! How convenient for this BITCH to blame your kid and never for one second think that she's not...um..."being all that she can be" with Noah. One wonders if this insn't what she always does when her particular brand of therapy doesn't work. Just pitiful. Take a cookie out of the cookie jar and give it to Noah. From me.
To call your little child a name like that is outrageous.
I wouldn't want that woman anywhere near my children, good for you for following your Mummy instinct.
So, wait . . . she told YOU that Noah was a brat? Seriously?
Even if Noah were the brattiest of brats, her calling him a name would still be more than inappropriate. Her job, as someone suggested above, is to make everyone in your family comfortable with services. What kind of therapist is she, anyway?
Complain, complain, complain. Be the cliched squeaky wheel. Your family--and lots of other therapy-seeking families--will benefit from your coming forward.
And what the hell--go ahead and slash her tires.
Good for you! No professional should ever speak about a child in those terms! I think pulling him out of OT was the right choice...sometimes a bad relationship with a therapist can be more harmful than no therapy at all!
I was going to comment on your last post, but my internet was being stupid...I was wondering if you had considered public preschool? If you have a child in EI, he is entitled to services in the school district setting when he turns three. FREE and appropriate services. Just something to think about for the future.
Good for you mama!
Hope the preschool goes wonderfully!
Good for you! My mouth dropped when I read she had called Noah a brat. It was unprofessional to say the least (which I know you know).
The picture you posted--I ask you, how do you keep from gobbling that boy's cheeks EVERY chance you get? He is one cute kiddo.
Wow-what a B-I-T-C-H. I am surprised at how unprofessional she was.
Argh. Brat? That sucks. I don't know you that well (hell, I don't know you really - just from stalking you on the internet) but I don't think you're the kind of person who stoops to the level of a pediatric OT that calls a child a brat. It wouldn't have served a purpose.
Instead you did what was right for Noah, FOR NOW. You can always go back and request a different OT if you feel like you want to try again.
You didn't wuss out. It takes time for trusting people to realize we're in a bad situation. You gave her the benefit of the doubt. That's what makes you a great person, and a great mom. I'm looking forward to hearing how preschool goes!
I've got another b-word for you, but it applies to the OT. I understand your stammering. It's called being stunned. Stunned silence. She's still a b-i-t-c-h.
OMG. I can't believe your therapist said that. I'm currently going to school to be an OT and that's just DISGRACEFUL to the profession. We're in this to deal with kids and others no matter how difficult they are being...that's what we're trained to do. But to sit there and say that to your face was pathetic and I hope that you find the courage to complain to some sort of management regarding that issue. She should be fired for that attitude.
I'm sure you're not the complain-and-get-someone-in-trouble-professionally type, but she was way out of line! I can't believe she would stigmatize him in such a way. When he clearly didn't deserve it. Even if she did spell it... you know how to spell.
She's clearly not doing her job very well.
I have not read all the comments, but here's my two cents: I would report this unprofessional behavior.
!!!!!
How completely unprofessional. Not to mention rude.
Good for you for making the change. I know my poor mom is still guilty for not believing me (over 20 years ago!) about how awful a teacher was until she found out first-hand, by having said teacher make catty remarks about another (very sweet, shy) girl in my class and then accuse me of lying to her (about something that my mother just happened to know was absolutely true). Sometimes a person's behavior is simply so inconceivable that you can't, well, conceive of it in order to head it off, and all you can do is react. Which you did!
Yes, rude, unprofessional, and should be fired. Some people's egos get in the way of doing a good job and bending to what the child needs instead of following their own rigid rules. But hooray for the progress he's made!!
If you're going to go into treating kids with special needs, shouldn't you have a little more patience?
If you're going to be working with parents of these kids, shouldn't you have a little more class?
Cripes.
Good for you, Amalah.
Holy balls.
She called him a name?! I think I'd have been dumbfounded, too. And then I would've preceded to spend every waking moment imagining all the things I should have done/said in response.
I hope she gets crotch-crickets, and that your little man kicks ass in preschool!
wow...even if Noah was completely acting out, that was totally uncalled-for and completely unprofessional. We have close friends whose kid can be a real snot, but I would never tell them their child was being a brat (just mumble it under my breath out of earshot, maybe).
Glad you found a preschool...I really hope it works out great and you have non-brat-callin' teachers there.
Wowee, was that woman out of line! I know you know that, but wowza, what kind of special needs therapist calls a child names?
It's a constant learning experience, isn't it? Not for our kids, I mean - for us! I've definitely developed more confidence in my opinions (and making those opinions known!) after traveling down the special-needs path for the last 5 years.
As someone who is *thisclose* to just flat out bitch slapping her son's teacher, I feel you girl. I feel ya.
I would also complain to the supervisor of the name caller. Although I am sure Satan is booked and it may take a while for him to get back to you.
I second the crotch crickets... with a nice dose of finger fungus and hairy moles. Better yet, let's just paint the unproffessional hag green and help her to find some ruby red slippers. Ahem, I am done. Please excuse my outburst. Please resume being an awesome Mom and go Noah!
i'll kick that woman's ass, and i'll wear a brass knuckle.
seriously, who does she think she is?
seriously? want us to send her some hate mail? b/c how is that at all okay to say to a child's mother - of a child that you work with?! girlfriend needs to find herself a NEW job if she's going to be saying stuff like that.
you're amazing amy!
Wow. I can't believe she said that. Please do report her. That is soo unprofessional and if she said that to you, she's saying it to other parents too, and this is NOT what parents need to hear.
He's not even my kid and I can't see past the 'brat' enough to move to the next part!
I am typeless. I don't even know that to type. She called your child a brat to your face? Un.be.liev.able.
Well she can take her ducky wash cloth and terrorize her own kids with it.
I know Noah has made tremendous strides but the way you described her? She always sounded like an idiot to me. And apparently she really is.
To "Ready for the Insults" - it actually doesn't matter whether Noah is or isn't a brat. I don't know either, never met him. But, I do know a professional has no right to call him a brat, particularly to his mother and definitely not when her strategies were not doing the job and another OT's were.
Good decision. Don't beat yourself up about not doing it sooner, because you didn't know.
I discovered recently in our struggle with infertility that, like any profession, there are good doctors or therapists, and there are bad ones.
You got a bad one.
Noah sounds like a wonderful little boy. I love hearing about him. And your pretty, pretty Coach purses too. :)
Wow, I can't believe she had the nerve to call him a brat. What an incredibly rude W-H-O-R-E.
Hi -
I've lurked for a long time, I'm tackling a lot of the same issues with my son. So sorry you had that experience with a therapist. We had a different but similar experience with a speech therapist and once we switched to a more experienced therapist the improvements have been non-stop. Kudos on enrolling Noah in preschool. My son is 3 1/2 and we've had him in preschool for quite a while and it's been so good for him. There are some painful times but it gets better and you'll be so proud of the little guy's accomplishments. Go Noah go.
A two year old can't BE a brat, because he or she is TWO!!! It is the job of a two-year-old to try out new things, and test limits, and feel independent, and have strong emotions, and worry about the unfamiliar, and learn how to be around people by having good models... And anyone whose job it is to help and support children and their families needs to know that implicitly.
What a B-i-t-c-h. You should have reported her at the least and then kicked her ass. How could a little guy with a face that angelic be a brat? Last month my boy who never cries unless he is hurt went on a 4 day non-stop crying jag and I took him to the hospital. The ER staff suggested it was just a tantrum. Turned out to be something serious that managed to fix itself but I called everyone I could to complain
I would call and report it!
PLEASE please please report her. She had no right, I don't care how frustrated she was.
I bet you wish you had said, "and you're a S-H-I-T-T-Y teacher."
Wow. Unprofessional much?
Yeah. That sucks. Even if they are brats, you never tell their parents that.
DUH.
(hehe).
What a total bitch. Seriously, how totally rude and crude and unprofessional and just downright mean? I want to go put the smackdown on her for Noah. GRR. Calling that sweet baby boy of yours a brat. She is obviously C-R-A-Z-Y.
I am so sorry that happened. I'd bet most of us understand the stunned silence - to get to the place where you are open to the opinions and advice of others, you have to let down your guard/bullshit filter.
I certainly hope she regrets what she said, as it is the reflection of the kind of person she was being that day more than anything else.
that OT calling him a Brat is extemely unprofessional and she should be immediatly reported to her supervisors for that. absolutely unacceptable behavior.
If you live near Kensington,MD i know an outstanding OT who works with sensory issues i can refer you too once you are ready to start OT again. My brother who wouldn't even touch family members, and forget strangers touching him without a meltdown. Through this OT he learned to hug which was huge.
Good call on leaving the other OT, Terrible terrible unprofessional women.
I'm sure that this comment will be one of a million in agreement- YOU DID THE RIGHT THING. A Mom should rely on her gut, and you did.
That woman is just lucky that you didn't jump up and bitch slap her for such an unprofessional and RUDE remark. That's great that you pulled him out and found a proper school for him.
Omigah. That face, I can't get over that face. I would've punched her. I would've at least yelled at her. But then again, that's why you're the momma and I'm the not-happy fan of the momma's writing. That's why you're a much better person than I.
I'm actually proud of you for doing all this, and having a great attitude while doing it. :-)
Two year olds are not deliberate brats. They're TWO. And this is from a mom of an almost 3 yr old who is... high spirited. And no, no one else may call him a brat.
Oh my god, I can't believe she called him a brat, that is just awful behaviour from a professional. Your son is beautiful, he Will find his way. My son is now 12 who had similar issues very young and is a joy. You are doing a great job, fair play to you!
The fact that she actually took the time to spell out B-R-A-T shows that she is a huge J-E-R-K.
Jules
House of Jules
Hi!
I have a great OT on 270/Montrose. Email me if you are interested!
Doris
I'll weigh in with everyone else who says you should make an issue of this with your ex-OT's supervisors. She at the very least needs some remedial training. You'll be doing her other patients a big favor by addressing it.
You are a great mom and I have mad respect for you.
Good for you for staying so calm. Now she will have nothing against you should you decide to go after her. which you should. with a vengeance.
OMG, I cant believe that evil woman called your son a brat. I'd call and complain. She shouldn't be allowed to work around children.
I'm glad you guys wont have to go through that anymore it seemed so hard on both of you.
And I'm sorry if I offended you in a previous post. I think you are a great mom and you are doing a great job with Noah. And which ever way you decide to go Noah will be Okay. He's a terrific lil guy.
Shut up! I cannot believe anyone would call that sweetbean a brat. I am so sorry you had to go through that and feel that way just because she couldn't express her frustration more appropriately. Honestly, I'd report that. It's unacceptable, period.