Life in Color
November 16, 2009
Honestly, he's done it for as long as I can remember -- as soon as Noah had the vocabulary down, he described songs in terms of color. One day he asked for the "yellow song," and sobbed while I offered up track after incorrect track of Raffi and Dan Zanes, desperately trying to figure out what the hell song he was talking about. A song about rainbows? That paint-mixing song from Blue's Clues? Big Bird? I finally gave up, assuming it was probably some blasted Moose and Zee segment from TV with a yellow background or yellow flower or something similarly random.
Then, later: a scary movie theme. Violins in minor key. Ominous timpanis. His eyes grew large and he fled the room. "NO RED SONG," he said. "OFF. NO."
For awhile, we assumed he was assigning colors in lieu of how the song made him feel. Yellow = happy songs, red = angry, scary. Then came pink songs and purple songs. And he learned how to express how he was feeling with real words, but the color thing persisted. I cycle through my iPod or the radio pre-sets in the car and he regularly makes his requests from the backseat. "No, Mommy," he says politely and articulately, "I want the yellow song."
Once a song has a stated color, it never changes. Yellow songs tend to be upbeat, playful. Most children's music, Jack Johnson. Although his current radio favorite, You're Gonna Go Far, Kid by The Offspring, is also a yellow song. Red songs are usually in a minor key, or somewhat dramatic sounding. Classical music, the theme from The Incredibles. Anything with a strong bass line or heavily orchestrated with woodwinds and strings is either purple or pink. Everything from The White Stripes to Coldplay to Beyonce has been lumped into the purple/pink realm.
Songs are never green and only rarely blue. Some songs don't have a color, Mommy. I mean, God.
Sometimes I catch him squinting, idly attempting to pinch or swat at the area in front of his face.
He is left-handed. He has a near-photographic memory for things he hears, and near-perfect pitch when he sings. I am officially pretty sure we can add synesthesia to our list of Quirks That Make You Go Hmmm.
It seems both entirely logical and yet grossly unfair for a kid who already struggles with ordering and processing his senses to be given the added complication of synesthesia. His teachers and therapists (all of whom I've had to educate on my theory; most of whom seem to think I'm talking New Age psychobabble nonsense) report that as noise levels go up, Noah's coping skills go down. He hides, he covers his ears, he wanders around in circles or becomes utterly fixated on a soothing, repetitive task. Amateur singing, whether by me or a teacher or anyone without a record deal, pretty much always drives him bonkers. "STOP!" he shouts. "YOU DON'T. YOU CAN'T." Certain music has the opposite effect -- simple piano music soothes and centers him, though so far his perfectionist nature has kept from experimenting very much on his own keyboard.
And yet, when I read about it, and about all the amazing musicians and artists and great thinkers who have had variations of synesthesia and used it as a gift, an enhancement, a privilege to see the world in a completely different way than the rest of us, I can't help but be more than a little impressed at just how much wonderfully mysterious potential is inside that quirky little brain.



=0) I was just singing you are my sunshine today and remembered the video of you and Noah singing it together. And then you posted this!
The idea that Noah's current favorite song is an Offspring song has totally made my day.
I once met a woman who tasted words, which is apparently a very rare form of synesthesia. It was fascinating and she was amazing. Just like your Noah.
I have no doubt that these "quirks" are preparing him for greatness.
(And apparently the word "Valerie" tastes like warm strawberry jam"to her.)
We really think my fiance is bipolar and we put his moods into colors, somedays he is green and so on. Sometimes just work to describe things better. Rock on Noah.
What a great talent to have!
My Noah also has an amazing ability to hear a song once and be able to sing it in the appropriate key -- not sure where he gets it from; or how he tolerates my terrible rendition of Twinkle Twinkle each and every night.
My 8 y/o Noah has a version of synesthesia. I didn't discover it until he was in kindergarten. For him, it's numbers that have colors. Some letters as well, although they don't seem to be as set in stone as the numbers. I think it's kind of cool ;)
I almost hate to ask this - because I personally know the financial affects of a kid who loves them, but have you tried guitar?
Please, please try piano lessons!
I totally do the thing where numbers have personalities, right down to how they interact with each other in mathematical equations. I learned my multiplication tables based on the social interaction of the numbers, not by memorization. I think it's beautiful that Noah can see and feel his music as well as hear it.
Synaesthesia is actually kind of cool. I am diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome, and letters and numbers have colours to me (as well as some words, but not many). I think it actually improves memory because you automatically have two sequences assisting you in remembering whatever it is - the sound and the colour, or the letters and the colours, or whatnot. I always had perfect spelling as a child, so I wonder if that had something to do with it - just as Noah's perfect sound memory may relate to his own synaesthesia?!
Oh, Amy... wow. Noah is just such an amazing little man. I've studied some pretty interesting pieces of alternative learning and synesthesia is just so enthralling. Perhaps this is key with which everything else can be unlocked for Noah- a real gift. Endless thanks for all you share!
I have a friend who has synesthesia. He's a composer now. I think it's absolutely fascinating to learn about.
For all of the concerns you've had about Noah's learning processes, you've got to give him credit for his always interesting diagnoses. :)
Hmmm. As always, hearing about Noah's quirks makes me wonder if I'll be seeing the same behaviour myself, a year or two down the line. At present, my troubled 2 year old just claps his hands over his ears and looks hunted - but has no verbal communication with which to express his evident discomfort. He's blatantly unappreciative of my guitar playing, too - even after I learnt that all-important third chord...
But reading about His Fabulousness could never be anything other than delightful - especially when you give us such edible photos! Totally gonna go far, kid.
I hope he some day realizes how incredible a gift it is to have that. It's beyond incredible really.
Amy,
What a wonderful thing. It is almost always the case that the things that make life so hard when we're young are also the things that make us all the things we love about ourselves as an adult. Teasing teaches compassion (usually)and hardship teaches gratitude for the small things.
At the risk of sounding like an 80 year old, it think all of Noahs hardships will build his character!
Your kid is so cool!
I think this is amazing. I hope you are still blogging when Noah and Ezra are grown so we can hear about the wonderful things they are doing.
George Gershwin! Rhapsody in Blue! I have no idea whether this is true, but they taught my sister in med school that George Gershwin had synesthesia. He apparently saw Rhapsody in Blue AS blue. Reportedly, he would tell the musicians who were rehearsing it, "A little bluer, please." Isn't that cool? (Tough for the musicians, but cool as hell.) It must be hard on you and Noah now, as synethesia could easily be seen as LITERAL sensory integration disorder. But, really, as disorders go, synesthesia is the coolest of the cool. People drop acid in often futile hopes of replicating it. I don't mean to sound callous saying so, but there's something magical about it.
I'm pretty sure that Noah is going to cure some disease or something equally HUGE. There's pure genius in that adorable little man.
On a much more mundane point, have there been any coping issues with the left handedness? My son is just two but I'm getting the sense that he is left handed.
I realize you have bigger issues to tackle but I've been wondering if I need to do anything other than get him special scissors.
So, do you have playlists by colors now on your iPod/iPhone?
my sister and i both experience synesthesia, although my sister far more accutely than i. she's currently getting her phd in genetics from stanford.
it's odd - i always thought of my synesthesia as a benefit. granted, i didn't have the added challenges that noah does, but i always thought i was lucky that i.. i don't know.. "understood" the fundamental nature of things more than other people. like, i felt sorry for people who DIDN'T know what color each letter of the alphabet is :-)
@drwendy - your numbers have personalities?
You have no idea how great it is to read that in your post. My numbers have always had personalities, too, but I assumed nobody else perceived this quality. I once told my dad and he was totally like "what? um, that's weird" so I never told anyone else...
OK, so I know this is super simplistic, given the amount of time and heartache you've had with trying to figure out all these quirks, but all I can think is:
Oh my gosh, that's so cool.
I have the number-personality brand of synaestheia like Ahmielyn, and I also have time-space related synaesthesia. It causes abstract concepts like time, numbers, etc present themselves concretely in my brain.
Like, take history. I see a very distinct, winding timeline that would be impossible to explain in text, but basically each unit of time (decades for the past 200 or so years, centuries before that) has it's own "feeling" and color and mood and yes, I am aware of how absolutely insane this sounds. Individual units of time like the year, the week, etc have their own distinct shapes and divisions too.
But yeah, I see it, and I remember seeing it for as long as I can remember, going back to about Noah's age. For as long as I've understood the concept of time, this is how I've seen it. It's just grown as my knowledge/understanding of the world has grown. I didn't realize for a really long time that other people's brains didn't work the same way. But I have a really great memory because of it, so woo! I really rock at pointless trivia games.
Everyone I've ever spoken to who has Synaesthesia has felt like it's only been an asset. It kind of just enhances the way you experience the world. Which might be part of why sounds in particular are so overwhelming for Noah at this stage. I never had the more pronounced sensory issues that Noah is experiencing right now, but I do have what my sister calls "super senses" and I do attribute it to whatever also caused the synaesthesia.
I think you have something there. Synesthesia can be frustrating but wonderful.
I highly recommend this book about synesthesia:
http://www.amazon.com/Blue-Cats-Chartreuse-Kittens-Synesthetes/dp/0805071873
Wow. That's actually really cool. Not that it isn't another challenge for Noah and you guys, but still, the brain is a remarkable thing, and Noah's is even more amazing.
I'm surprised at the therapists though. I thought Synesthesia was a pretty documented condition these days. Sounds like they're behind the 8 ball on this one.
What a very cool and fun quirk to have!
I'm pretty sure quirky is a synonym for beautiful.
http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/synesthesia/
What an amazing gift your son is! Thanks for sharing him with us.
I used to be the same way with songs. Sharp brassy instrumentals are still orange to me. :-)
I don't have anything as interesting or mysterious as synesthesia but I have always had extreme sensitivity to noise, light, color. Especially sharp noises. It's hard being an Army Brat when you can't stand the sound of a marching band! And fireworks are torture. Having always been considered a "sensitive" child (ah, the 70s) I wonder what kind of testing I would have gone through...
Noah is so interesting to me, I think he will have a lot to reveal to us at some point. And Ezra as well!
What do you make of the investigation of the air in front of his face? All I can think is auras, but I'm dubious that you were going there.
I'm a synesthete. I see colors in numbers and letters, and I think it's contributed to my ability as a writer (and my inability to understand math). Nevertheless, I see it as a wonderful gift from God. I'll never forget when I realized that everyone doesn't see life in the same way. It was shocking. I mean, how could 6 be anything but female, and how could 9 be anything but green?
I also have near-perfect pitch. One of the biggest travesties in my life is not picking up the violin. I suppose there's still time, though.
If he likes soothing piano music, I highly recommend Erik Satie played by Pascal Roge. Some of my favorite stuff on earth.
We once came home to our dear and only nonfamily babysitter telling us she couldn't sit for us anymore. My husband asked some questions and found out she had tried to sing to our son. After his usual "don't sing! don't sing!" didn't work, he went with "I hate you," out of frustration/to get her to stop. We told her we couldn't sing to him either.
What a neat kid you've got yourself there! :)
Fascinating. I can't stop trying to find more information about the subject now because it's just so interesting and cool! Thank you so much for sharing things like this. Noah is such an amazing little boy.
Wow. So not a quirk, and so a gift. Think of how much so many of us enjoy music, and how beautiful it often seems. Then think of being able to experience it in color. I'm jealous--or as jealous as one can be of someone as cute as Noah.
Every single person I know with some variety of synesthesia (tasting or seeing notes, etc) is both an AMAZING musician and ridiculously smart and doing amazing things. It probably frustrates him now, but I feel like its going to be a big asset in the long run.
I experience both the color and personality aspect, though in something of a muted form. It's hard for me to come up with anything specific while I'm not experiencing it. Music produces patterns of shifting shapes and colors when I close my eyes.
My memory is not quite photographic, but highly associative, and I think part of it is the engagement of multiple senses/emotions. This builds up more and stronger neural pathways.
I didn't consciously realize I did this or that not everybody does this until I started reading about Asperger's. My son was just diagnosed and I don't know if he experiences the world similarly.
i think i fell in love just now. YOU DON'T YOU CAN'T exactly
I have thought for a long time that I have a touch of synesthesia, numbers have color to them and pain in particular has color attached. I was amazed to find out that my mom couldn't imagine the difference between a bronze pain (menstural) and sliver thread pain (pinched nerve). I was 34 when I learned that she didn't get it.
As an adult, it is no big deal.
How interesting. My husband has always told me how numbers are associated with color for him and he assumed that everyone saw it that way.
It amuses me when he'll tell me things like blue plus green equals 9.
He also has an almost photographic memory and is pretty amazing. So. Those quirks? they can grow into wonderful talents and passionate people.
Wow, what an amazing trait. I remember the first time I heard about synethesia on NPR. I thought people with that are lucky to live in such a world of color.
I'm sure it's confusing and sometimes scary for him now. I hope someday he thinks of himself as lucky and amazing.
I have synesthesia. For me it's a jumble of colors and textures associated with smells and taste (my poor husband hears things like “that chicken has too many points, it shouldn’t be that smooth yellow) (YEAH! Sucks to be him!) Please don't think it unfair that Noah should have this amazing ability, he will have a much wider, richer reality. I promise.
I can recommend some amazing books if you’re interested (and if you’re interested in one day exploring the depths of his synesthesia, some amazing doctors who are specialists in our colorful, shape-filled world.)
You should read "Born On a Blue Day."
My daughter and I both have a vry low level of synesthesia; sometimes I wish it were more. :)
My son is autistic and he's always had a special bond with music and it's just, wow. Amazing. AMAZING.
I have personification synesthesia and for the longest time I had no idea that it had a name. Then I met a girl who can hear colors and tastes words and she told me about synesthesia. It was one of the most amazing moments of my adult life to realize that there were other people who thought this way! Others thought it was crazy enough that I considered certain numbers as "facing" left or right, let alone that 5 is pure evil and 6 is his stupid sidekick.
I have one friend who will sometimes call when she's having a bad day and ask, "Tell me about the numbers again!" She is absolutely tickled by my the soap opera in my head that is counting and algebra.
This made me smile. Huge.